@drago354 wrote:
Well I think I've narrowed it down to something on the Procurve VLAN 10. I can connect 2 devices directly into the ports that are part of the same VLAN 10 on the procurve and they cannot ping each other. I can connect the same devices into VLAN 10 directly into the Juniper and they work fine.
Well... this is a Juniper support forum and it's been a while since I've had a ProCurve in front of me...
I don't think you want a "trunk" port configured on the ProCurve. I don't think it means what I think you think it means. A "trunk" in this context means a LAG or aggregation port, LACP/802.3ad, etc.
Confusing terminology -- yes. No doubt.
You've got a few problems, it looks like...
Your descriptions say that the Sonicwall X4 interface goes to HP port 45 on VLAN 10, but your Procurve description says port 45 is part of VLAN 1. You've got ports 46-48 tagged in VLAN 10 on the HP, but no untagged ports. Do ports 46-48 connect to another switch?
How about if you cleaned up your topology and configs a bit... maybe your topology could look something like this:
(WAN)
|
|-----------|---(X1)
| Sonicwall |
-(X0)-|-----------|-(X4)-
| |
|(VLAN 1) (VLAN 10)|
| |
---(2)--|-----------|--(3)
| Procurve |
(1)--|-----------|--(4-45)--(VLAN 1)--[...]
| |
|(Trunk) ----(46-48)--(VLAN 10)--[...]
|
(0)--|-----------|
| EX2200 |
|-----------|--(1-45)--(VLAN 1)--[...]
|
----(45-47)--(VLAN 10)--[...]
You can (from what I can see) delete the trunk port config on the ProCurve and the cleaned up ProCurve config would look like this:
vlan 1
name "DEFAULT_VLAN"
untagged 1-2,4-45,A1-A4
ip address 192.168.1.2 255.255.255.0
exit
vlan 10
name "WLAN"
ip address 192.168.15.2 255.255.255.0
untagged 3,46-48
tagged 1
exit
Based on that, your description of your network now looks like this:
Sonicwall Tz210
X0 - 192.168.1.x - to Procurve port 2 (VLAN 1 - default VLAN)
X1 - WAN
X4 - 192.168.15.x - to Procurve port 3 (VLAN 10 - WLAN)
HP Procurve
Port 1 - trunk to juniper ge-0/0/0
Port 2 - to Sonicwall X0 (VLAN 1 - default VLAN)
Port 3 - to Sonicwall X4 (VLAN 10 - WLAN)
Port 4-45 - to end stations/clients (VLAN 1 - default VLAN)
(VLAN 1 IP 192.168.1.2)
Port 46-48 - to end stations/clients (VLAN 10 - WLAN)
(VLAN 10 IP 192.168.15.2)
Juniper
ge-0/0/0 - trunk to Procurve port 1
ge-0/0/1 - ge-/0/0/45 - to end stations/clients (VLAN 1 - default VLAN)
(VLAN 1 IP - 192.168.1.5)
ge-0/0/46 - ge-0/0/47 - to end stations/clients (VLAN 10 - WLAN)
(VLAN 10 IP - 192.168.15.3)
Now you've got another problem... your EX is going to want to route between VLANs 1 and 10, because you've configured L3 interfaces on both VLANs. I think, based on what I'm seeing, that you want your Sonicwall to do the routing and your switches to just be switches.
Assuming your gateways on the client machines point to the Sonicwall, this shouldn't cause a major issue, but it can certainly start to get confusing on down the line. I'd recommend that eventually you set your EX to only have an IP on one VLAN, just so that you can access it for management via SSH/etc.