Ethernet Switching
Highlighted
Ethernet Switching

ERPS and STP

09.16.11   |  
‎09-16-2011 10:38 AM

Is it necessary to run spanning tree in a metro ethernet network that relies on ERPS for fault tolerance?  It would seem counterproductive to me to run both.

4 REPLIES
Ethernet Switching

Re: ERPS and STP

09.16.11   |  
‎09-16-2011 09:41 PM
yes, stp has role to play, when any packet resilient protocol like ERPS (G.8032v2) or Foundry's MRP / Huwaei's RRPP / Cisco's REP is already running on the metro ...

these protocol are suitable to provide ring protection over metro-rings in comparison to conventional STP/MSTP/RSTP which is used normal ethernet scenarios ...

regards

Hafiz Muhammad Farooq
JNCIE-SEC, JNCIP-SEC, JNCIS-SEC, JNCIS-FWV
JNCIS-SP, JNCIS-SA, JNCIA-JUNOS
IBM Qradar Deployment Professional

[Please mark it as Accepted Solution if it works, Kudos if you like]

Ethernet Switching

Re: ERPS and STP

09.17.11   |  
‎09-17-2011 07:37 AM

Thanks for the response, but I'm still not clear.  If ERPS is used to block ports on a ring, then what purpose does MSTP serve, seeing's how it could take up to a minute to propogate topology changes?

Ethernet Switching

Re: ERPS and STP

[ Edited ]
09.19.11   |  
‎09-19-2011 12:29 PM

Hi,

 

MSTP does not take a minute to converge, it's based on RSTP(inside MSTP domain) and it's really fast.

If properly engineered it gives really good results.

Regarding your question, ERPS only helps when you have ring topologies but it's not suitable for mesh ones, so in order to be on the safe side you better run both, otherwise you risc a lot as any unexpected loop can bring the whole network down.

Regards,
Dumitru Papana
Ethernet Switching

Re: ERPS and STP

09.26.11   |  
‎09-26-2011 04:19 AM
To follow on a bit from Dumitru's post - ERPs and others require the topology to be statically configured, generally through e use of a "carrier" VLAN for the ERPs token which is used to form the ring.

MSTP on the other hand caters for dynamic and unexpected topologies (the human factor), because it will converge any topology thrown at it to be loop-free.

There are definitely ways to mitigate against loops in a metro environment so that you no longer need MSTP (shut down non-ring ports, tunnel or filter customer L2 protocols etc), but at the end of the day it comes down to risk.

Cheers,
Ben
Ben Dale
JNCIP-ENT, JNCIP-SP, JNCIP-DC, JNCIE-SEC #63
Juniper Ambassador
Follow me @labelswitcher